Claim scrutiny: What is this process, and how does it impact health insurance claims?

Many of us purchase health insurance for peace of mind during our tough times. But the purchase of health insurance is just the starting point. Claims have to be filed for every hospitalisation and relevant documents have to be submitted from the policyholder’s side for the mechanism to work. The insurer will then have to go through your paperwork and ultimately decide whether your claim stands or not. Claim scrutiny has been put in place to safeguard the interests of the policyholders and insurers. Here’s everything you need to know about this process.

Many of us purchase health insurance for peace of mind during our tough times. But the purchase of health insurance is just the starting point. Claims have to be filed for every hospitalisation and relevant documents...
Many of us purchase health insurance for peace of mind during our tough...
Health insurance should help you focus on recovery, not bills.

Plans start at just ₹21/day*.

key-features-0

We pay 100% of your hospital bills

From syringes to surgeries

key-features-1

No limit on hospital room rent

No compromises on recovery

UID: 5908|*T&Cs Apply
background-image-desktop-widget

What is claim scrutiny?

Claim scrutiny is the process through which the insurer or the third-party administrator (TPA) checks the validity of the claim filed by the policyholder. They have a checklist that the claim has to pass through to get approval. Claims that don’t pass this checklist are rejected, and the policyholder will have to settle with the hospital using their own money. In some cases, the documentation may not be sufficient to make the case for the policyholder. Additional documents may be requested in such cases.

How does claim scrutiny work?

Here’s how the process of claim scrutiny works. The process is applied to both cashless claims and reimbursements. The process begins once the policyholder initiates a claim for the treatment with the insurer/TPA.

Reviewing documentation

The policyholder provides relevant documentation to support their claim to the insurer/TPA. Once these documents are received, they are reviewed by the stakeholders to check them for accuracy. These documents include medical bills, consultation notes, discharge summaries, and diagnostic test reports. With cashless claims, this process starts with the pre-authorisation documents. In the case of reimbursements, it starts once the claim is made post-hospitalisation.

Checking for compliance

Health insurance policies come with a set of ironclad terms and conditions and exclusions. Claim scrutiny is applied to check for compliance with the policy. This could include the need for treatment/hospitalisation, checking for waiting periods for pre-existing conditions, any sublimits that may have been crossed, and whether the disease in question has been excluded from coverage.

Preventing fraudulent claims

Claim scrutiny is also an important tool when it comes to fraud prevention. Fraud can happen in many forms when it comes to health insurance. Claims can be made for treatments/services that have not been performed. Policyholders can also misrepresent their health history and pre-existing conditions. Hospitals may overcharge for certain procedures or fabricate the need for hospitalisation to claim insurance benefits. Claim scrutiny is used to find such fraud, as they have a negative impact on the bottom line of the insurers.

What can lead to claim rejection during scrutiny?

Falsification/non-disclosure of information: Not disclosing pre-existing conditions and other medical details can lead to rejection of claims post-claim scrutiny.

Waiting period

If the claim falls within the waiting period stipulated in the health insurance plan, it will not be entertained by the insurance company.

Carousel Circle Pattern

Exclusions

There are certain diseases, treatments, and conditions that the insurer will not cover. If the claim is related to these exclusions, it will be rejected during scrutiny.

Carousel Circle Pattern

Incomplete/incorrect documentation

Documents such as a discharge summary, diagnostic reports, and medical bills form the backbone of a claim. They have to be complete and accurate for the claim to be approved.

Carousel Circle Pattern

Mismatch of data

If there is a mismatch in the data points provided by the policyholder, such as name, age, and treatment performed, the claim can be rejected.

Carousel Circle Pattern

Empanelled hospitals

Cashless claims from hospitals that are not empanelled with the insurer will face rejection.

Carousel Circle Pattern

Unnecessary treatments

The insurer will only cover treatments that are deemed to be medically necessary for the patient. Treatments that are performed for sheer convenience and have no impact on the overall health of the patient will not be approved for coverage by the insurer.

Carousel Circle Pattern

What can policyholders do for a smoother claims process?

Here’s a simple checklist for policyholders to follow for a smoother claims process:

  • Understand your health insurance policy in total. This includes terms and conditions, waiting period, survival period, inclusions, sublimits, room rent caps, exclusions, etc. 
  • Disclosure of pre-existing conditions and medical history at the time of policy purchase is very important. Failure to do so ends with claim rejection and can escalate to legal action
  • Keep a record of all the relevant documents, including discharge summaries, diagnostic reports, doctor’s consultation notes, and medical bills. Submit these documents as and when required
  • Ensure that you are at a network hospital if you are opting for cashless claims, and plan your pre-authorisation accordingly

Claim scrutiny is a very extensive process. Documents are thoroughly vetted by experienced personnel, and these days, advanced technology such as AI has been introduced to keep the process fair and fast. Policyholders should also be proactive. They must ensure that they submit relevant documents in a timely manner and without hiding facts so that their claims can sail through.

Frequently asked questions

They evaluate the claim against certain pre-defined criteria. This includes the terms and conditions of the plan, if the treatment is medically necessary, documentation presented by the policyholder, its accuracy, etc. If the claims satisfy these criteria, the insurer will approve your claim. If they need more supporting documents, they will request the same from the policyholder.

There is a grievance redressal system offered by the health insurance company to address your issues. If this process doesn’t give you a satisfactory answer, you can approach an insurance ombudsman to resolve the matter. You can also file a case against the insurer in the court of law.

Author photo Icon

Written by Roocha Kanade

2.5K Linkedin Followers Author dot Icon

Reviewed by Dr. Harshita Dahiya Author info Icon

Health Insurance content enthusiast who turns complex topics into easy, binge-worthy reads—fueled by SEO, creativity, and way too much chai! Loves juggling multiple projects, cracking impossible deadlines, and sprinkling humor into the mix. When not geeking out over digital trends, you'll find her lurking on Quora and Reddit, planning the next getaway, or passionately decoding all things health and insurance!

Explore Our Comprehensive Health Insurance Options