TROP vs ULIP: What is Best for Protection with Returns

When considering between TROP and ULIP, it is necessary to understand their key features. Both plans provide life protection, but they offer returns in two fundamentally different ways. With TROP, if you survive the policy term, you will receive a refund for the premiums you paid. Plus, the returns are fixed and low-risk. In contrast, ULIP invests part of your premium into market-linked funds, where returns depend on market performance and are not guaranteed. This article provides useful information to help determine which plan is better for your needs based on your risk appetite, investment goals, and more.

When considering between TROP and ULIP, it is necessary to understand their key...

Term Life Insurance that Welcomes Change

Life Cover Starting @ just ₹18/day*

Change Your Policy Term

As per your life stage and commitments

Hassle-Free Claim Settlement

99.38% Claim settlement ratio*

Smart Income Tax Savings

Save up to ₹54,600* on your taxes

ARN: L0088 | *T&Cs Apply

Understanding TROP Plans

TROP stands for Term Insurance with Return of Premium. It is a type of term life insurance that offers life coverage with a refund of all premiums paid if the policyholder survives till the end of the policy term. It provides guaranteed returns with no market risk. It is ideal for those who want financial protection for their loved ones with assured benefits.

Understanding ULIP Plans

ULIP stands for Unit Linked Insurance Plan. It is a type of life insurance plan that combines life coverage with investment opportunities. In ULIP, part of the premiums you pay is used to provide life insurance coverage, while another portion is invested in market-linked funds such as equity, debt, or hybrid (combination of both). This simply means that the performance of the returns will depend on market performance.

It is a good choice for those looking for higher market-linked gains. If you decide to purchase ULIPs, you must know that they provide wealth creation and protection, but they come with higher investment risks and premiums.

TROP vs ULIP: Detailed Comparison

This is an investment component comparison between ULIP and TROP, highlighting how each plan approaches returns and risk.

Feature	TROP	ULIP

Objectives	Protection-focused with assured refund of premiums	Wealth creation through market-linked investments
Returns	Refund of the entire premiums paid (guaranteed if survival)	Market-linked returns; maturity value depends on market performance and is not guaranteed
Risks	Risk-free; assured premium return	Subject to market volatility and investment risks
Costs	Generally lower charges, largely premium-based	Slightly higher costs due to fund management, allocation, and administration fees
Flexibility	Fixed structure with no control over investments	Flexible- allows switching of funds and partial withdrawals

ULIP vs TROP: Key Factors to Consider Before Choosing a Plan

As you consider a TROP plan or a ULIP, the following are important points to review:

Risk Appetite

TROP plans provide assured returns that suit conservative investors well. ULIPs are suitable for those who have a higher risk appetite. Since ULIPs provide linked returns, risk tolerance is an important consideration when choosing a plan.

Investment Goals

TROP would be better for short and medium-term goals, such as loan repayments with a return. A ULIP is better for long-term goals as it allows growth based on market-linked returns.

Cost Impacts

TROP plans are generally simpler and have fewer costs associated with them as they do not have an investment element. ULIPs have many costs associated with them, such as management fees, premium allocation, and mortality costs, which will add to the overall costs of the plan.

Flexibility

ULIPs are also flexible, as policyholders can choose between equity, debt, or balanced funds when they purchase their plan based on their risk appetite and switch between funds during the policy period. In terms of flexibility, TROP policies offer much less flexibility than ULIPs. Once the premium and policy term are locked in, they generally remain fixed for the duration of the policy.

Tax Implications

Both offer tax benefits on premiums under Section 80C and tax-free maturity under Section 10(10D), subject to certain conditions.

Time Horizon

TROP plans are generally suitable for medium to long-term tenures, ULIPs, being market-linked investment products, generally require a longer time horizon of 10 years or more.

Conclusion

The decision to opt for the Return on Premium Plan or ULIP is based on your financial target. TROP plans provide guaranteed returns, minimum expense, and financial security for your loved ones. ULIPs combine life coverage with investment opportunities. It offers more flexibility, such as switching funds or making partial withdrawals. TROP does not allow such changes but provides predictable outcomes. When conducting an investment component comparison, parameters like risk, cost, expense ratio, and volatility, it is crucial to carefully evaluate parameters such as risk, cost, expense ratio, and volatility to select the plan that best aligns with your financial objectives.

FAQs

1. What is the difference between ETF and ULIP?

ETFs (Exchange-Traded Funds) are market investments solely, with no life cover, unlike ULIPs. ULIPs provide life coverage with market-linked investments, tax benefits, the option of switching funds, partial protection, and long-term savings.

2. What is the difference between ULIP and pure term insurance?

ULIPs provide life coverage with investment opportunities. Term insurance offers pure life coverage with no maturity benefits if you survive the policy term.

3. What are the disadvantages of ULIP?

There are several charges, like premium allocation or other fees for fund management.

4. Which is better, FD or ULIP?

Fixed Deposits (FD) are a low-risk, fixed-return investment option. A ULIP is essentially a life insurance plan with investments in equity and debt markets. Thus, it has a higher return potential but generally requires a longer lock-in period.

5. What does ULIP mean?

ULIP stands for Unit Linked Insurance Plan. It’s a type of life insurance that combines investment and insurance.

6. What are the advantages of a Unit Linked Insurance Plan?

ULIPs give you life cover as well as the opportunity to grow your money through market-based investments. You will also have the flexibility to choose and switch funds, as well as tax benefits.

Written by Neviya Laishram

1.7K Linkedin Followers

Reviewed by Vaibhav Kumar Kaushik

A senior editor with years of expertise, she fine-tunes content that connects, converts, and builds trust. She transforms heavy life insurance concepts into clear, aha-moment reads. Writing is her passion, and thinking ahead is second nature. When not wrangling words, she’s crushing game levels because every challenge is a puzzle waiting to be solved.